Case Number: 11-0593

  • 04/30/2014
    Service - Order

    Copy of Amendatory Order served electronically to parties.
  • 04/29/2014
    Order Entered - Amendatory

    Amendatory Order entered.
  • 03/11/2014
    Filing - Motion

    Commonwealth Edison Company's Motion to Correct the March 5, 2014 Final Order, filed by Eimer Stahl LLP. (Electronic)
  • 03/06/2014
    Service - Order

    Copy of Final Order served electronically to parties.
  • 03/05/2014
    Order Entered - Final

    Final Order entered.
  • 02/25/2014
    Filing - Appearance

    Notice of Substitution of Counsel and Appearance on behalf of Commonwealth Edison Company, filed by Eimer Stahl LLP. (Electronic)
  • 01/23/2014
    Transcript - Received

    CORRECTED ORAL ARGUMENT Transcript - October 24, 2013, received.
  • 11/26/2013
    Filing - Motion

    Commonwealth Edison Company’s Motion to Correct the Transcript of the Oral Argument of October 24, 2013, filed by Eimer Stahl, LLP. (Electronic)
  • 11/13/2013
    Transcript - Received

    ORAL ARGUMENT Transcript - October 24, 2013, received.
  • 10/24/2013
    Oral Argument - Heard and Taken Under Advisement

    Oral Argument Heard by the Commission and Taken under Advisement.
  • 10/23/2013
    Service - Notice

    Notice given by the Administrative Law Judge of the attached Oral Argument Schedule. Notice served electronically to parties.
  • 10/08/2013
    Service - Notice

    Notice given by the Administrative Law Judge of the instructions set out by the Illinois Commerce Commission (“Commission”) with respect to Oral Argument for Docket No. 11-0593, our investigation into Commonwealth Edison Company’s compliance with the efficiency standard requirement of Section 8-103 of the Public Utilities Act. Oral Argument is scheduled for Thursday, October 24, 2013 at 9:30 A.M. in Chicago. Consistent with Section 200.850(b) of the Rules of Practice, Oral Argument will be limited to parties having filed briefs in this Docket. In addition to the requirements contained in Section 200.850(c) of the Rules of Practice, the Commission herein sets the following additional guidelines:
    (1) The scope of Oral Argument is as follows: A. With reference to “banking” energy savings, please address the following topics:
    Does Section 8-103 of the Public Utilities Act permit a utility to “bank” excess energy savings from a previous year, to be applied in the following year? Does Section 8-103 of the Public Utilities Act permit a utility to “bank” excess energy savings cumulatively from multiple years? If Section 8-103 does permit a utility to “bank” energy savings in excess of its energy savings goal, should that incremental amount be based on the overall energy savings goal shared with DCEO, or should that amount be based only on the utility portion of the shared savings goal? How does allowing “banking” affect the long-term goals of the energy savings program?B. Is it reasonable to apply new data or information related to a program retrospectively in order to determine that program’s energy savings? Or for that matter, can it be used to decide the ultimate success or failure of that program as it pertains to satisfying the overall energy efficiency goals? (2) ComEd will have 20 minutes for its argument, while any other party wishing to argue these issues will have 15 minutes. The allotted time includes Commissioner questions and responses from counsel. Parties may reserve time for rebuttal. Unless parties have filed joint briefs in this Docket, parties are prohibited from pooling or sharing their time allotment. (3)Irrespective of the issues listed above, the parties should be prepared to answer any question regarding the record or the pertinent law.
    (4) Parties intending to present Oral Argument must notify Nicole Luckey (nluckey@icc.illinois.gov) and ALJ Sainsot (csainsot@icc.illinois.gov) with a list of attorneys presenting Oral Argument, and on which topics presentations will be made, by 5:00 P.M. on Tuesday, October 22, 2013. (5) Parties presenting arguments shall provide Ms. Luckey and ALJ Sainsot with exhibits, if any, that will be used for Oral Argument by 5:00 P.M. on Tuesday, October 22, 2013. (6) If an attorney is in need of an accommodation for any visual aid, counsel must inform Ms. Luckey and ALJ Sainsot by 5:00 P.M. on Tuesday, October 22, 2013, as to the specifics of the accommodation needed. Notice served electronically to parties.
  • 09/19/2013
    Service - Commission Action

    Notice of Commission Action served electronically to parties advising them of the action of the Commission on September 18, 2013.
  • 09/18/2013
    Commission Action - Oral Argument

    The Commission in conference GRANTED the Request for Oral Argument, filed by Commonwealth Edison Company on July 31, 2013.
  • 08/07/2013
    Briefs - Reply to Exceptions

    Reply Brief on Exceptions of the Staff of the Illinois Commerce Commission filed. (electronic)
  • 08/07/2013
    Briefs - Reply to Exceptions

    Reply Brief on Exceptions of the People of the State of Illinois filed. (electronic)
  • 08/07/2013
    Briefs - Reply to Exceptions

    Reply Brief on Exceptions of Commonwealth Edison Company, filed by Eimer Stahl LLP. (Electronic)
  • 07/31/2013
    Briefs - On Exceptions

    Brief on Exceptions of the Staff of the Illinois Commerce Commission, filed. (Electronic)
  • 07/31/2013
    Briefs - On Exceptions

    Brief on Exceptions of Commonwealth Edison Company, filed by Eimer Stahl LLP. ORAL ARGUMENT REQUESTED (Electronic)
  • 07/31/2013
    Briefs - On Exceptions

    Brief on Exceptions and Exceptions of the People of the State of Illinois, filed. (Electronic)
  • 07/18/2013
    Service - Proposed Order

    Proposed Order served electronically to parties.
  • 07/10/2013
    Filing - Notice

    Notice of Withdrawal of Counsel, filed by Kelley Drye & Warren LLP on behalf of the Illinois Power Agency. (Electronic)
  • 06/13/2013
    Filing - Draft/Suggested Order

    Staff of the Illinois Commerce Commission's Draft Proposed Order, filed. (Electronic)
  • 06/13/2013
    Filing - Draft/Suggested Order

    Draft Proposed Order Submitted by Commonwealth Edison Company, filed by Eimer Stahl LLP. (Electronic)
  • 06/04/2013
    Briefs - Reply/Response

    Reply Brief of the Staff of the Illinois Commerce Commission, filed. (Electronic)
  • 06/04/2013
    Briefs - Reply/Response

    Commonwealth Edison Company's Reply Brief, filed by Eimer Stahl LLP. (Electronic)
  • 06/04/2013
    Briefs - Reply/Response

    Reply Brief of the People of the State of Illinois, filed. (Electronic)
  • 05/21/2013
    Briefs - Initial

    Initial Brief of the Staff of the Illinois Commerce Commission, filed. (Electronic)
  • 05/21/2013
    Briefs - Initial

    Initial Brief of Commonwealth Edison Company, filed by Eimer Stahl LLP. (Electronic)
  • 05/21/2013
    Briefs - Initial

    Initial Brief of the People of the State of Illinois filed. (electronic)
  • 04/30/2013
    Transcript - Received

    Transcript - April 16, 2013, received.
  • 04/23/2013
    Service - Hearing Continuance Letter

    Notice given by the Administrative Law Judge that the hearing has been continued generally. Notice served electronically to parties.
  • 04/16/2013
    Hearing Report - Heard and Continued

    Heard by Administrative Law Judge Sainsot and continued generally.
  • 04/16/2013
    Hearing Report - Exhibits

    e-Docket: Also admitted was ComEd 5.0, which is the evaluation reports that were filed on e-docket on 6/21/13 (consisting of the affidavit of Jeffrey Erickson; a Summary Report, and reports 1-12 regarding various performance measures). Adm on P. 36-37 of Trans.
  • 04/16/2013
    Hearing Report - Exhibits

    ComEd Exhibits: 1.0 corr., 2.0, 3.0 & 4.0 (Brandt direct testimony, rebuttal testimony, surrebuttal testimony and affidavit, respectively) Adm in Trans P. 36-37
    Staff Exhibits: 1.0, 1.1-1.5, (1.4 is confidential) 2.0 and 2.1, which are, respectively Hinman direct testimony with exhibits, Hinman rebuttal testimony, and 3.0 affidavit. Adm in Trans P.44-45
    Staff cross Exhibits: 1 Adm in Trans P. 44 and Cross Exhibit 2 - Adm in Trans P. 58-59
    DCEO Exhibits: 1.0 and 1.1 which are the direct testimony of Mrzowski and attachment. ) Adm in Trans P.51-52
    DCEO Exhibits: 2.1-2.10 (late filed on 4/19/13 with leave from the ALJ) performance measure reports regarding DCEO programs. ) Adm in Trans P. 51-52
    AG Exhibits: 1.0, 2.0 Corr. and 3.0, which are Mosenthal direct test, rebuttal and affidavit, respectively. ) Adm in Trans P. 59-60
    ALL THE ABOVE EXHIBITS WERE TENDERED IN HARD COPY
  • 04/16/2013
    Hearing Report - Administrative Law Judge Ruling

    DCEO was granted leave to late-file DCEO Ex. 2.0, which is the measure report(s) that concern DCEO by 4/19/13.
    Post-trial Briefing is as follows: Post-trial briefs to be filed and served by 5/21/13. Reply Briefs, if any, to be filed & served by 6/4/13. Draft orders to be filed and served by 6/13/13.
  • 04/16/2013
    Transcript - Pending

    Transcript pending.
  • 04/02/2013
    Filing - Memorandum

    Pre-Trial Memorandum of the Staff of the Illinois Commerce Commission, filed. (Electronic)
  • 04/02/2013
    Filing - Memorandum

    Commonwealth Edison Company's Pretrial Memorandum, filed by Eimer Stahl LLP. (Electronic)
  • 04/02/2013
    Filing - Memorandum

    The People of the State of Illinois' Pre Trial Memorandum, filed. (Electronic)
  • 01/25/2013
    Transcript - Received

    Transcript - January 10th, 2013, filed.
  • 01/11/2013
    Service - Hearing Continuance Letter

    Hearing continued by the Administrative Law Judge to April 16, 2013, in Chicago at 10:00 A.M., for evidentiary. Notice also given by the Administrative Law Judge of the following schedule: Staff and the Parties shall file and serve prehearing memos on or before April 2, 2013; Post trial Briefs will be filed and served by April 30, 2013;
    Reply briefs, if any, will be filed and served by May 7, 2013; and Draft orders will be filed and served by May 14, 2013. Notice served electronically to parties.
  • 01/10/2013
    Hearing Report - Heard and Continued

    Heard by Administrative Law Judge Sainsot and continued to April 16, 2013, in Chicago, at 10:00 A.M., for evidentiary hearing.
  • 01/10/2013
    Transcript - Pending

    Transcript pending.
  • 01/04/2013
    Transcript - Received

    Transcript - December 19, 2012, received.
  • 12/27/2012
    Service - Hearing Continuance Letter

    Hearing continued by the Administrative Law Judge to January 10, 2013, in Chicago at 1:00 P.M. Notice served electronically to parties.
  • 12/19/2012
    Hearing Report - Heard and Continued

    Heard by Administrative Law Judge Sainsot and continued to January 10, 2013, in Chicago, at 1:00 P.M.
  • 12/19/2012
    Transcript - Pending

    Transcript pending.
  • 12/12/2012
    Service - Notice

    Notice given by the Administrative Law Judge that the hearing scheduled for December 19, 2012, in Chicago, at 11:00 A.M., has been changed to 1:00 P.M. Notice served electronically to parties.
  • 10/19/2012
    Filing - Appearance

    Notice of Appearance of the People of the State of Illinois, filed. (Electronic)
  • 10/18/2012
    Service - Notice

    Notice given by the Administrative Law Judge that the schedule in the above entitled matter has changed as follows:
    Staff and intervenor testimony is due to be filed and served on November 1, 2012, and ComEd surrebuttal testimony due to be filed and served on December 5, 2012. Notice also given by the Administrative Law Judge that the status hearing in scheduled for November 27, 2012, has been continued to December 19, 2012, in Chicago at 11:00 A.M. Parties advised electronically.
  • 09/20/2012
    Filing - Appearance

    Appearance of the Illinois Department of Commerce and Economic Opportunity, filed. (Electronic)
  • 09/07/2012
    Transcript - Received

    Transcript - August 23, 2012, received.
  • 08/24/2012
    Service - Hearing Continuance Letter

    Hearing continued by the Administrative Law Judge to November 27, 2012, in Chicago at 11:30 A.M., for status. Notice served electronically to parties.
  • 08/23/2012
    Transcript - Pending

    Transcript Pending.
  • 08/23/2012
    Hearing Report - Heard and Continued

    Heard by Administrative Law Judge Sainsot and continued to November 27, 2012, in Chicago at 11:30 A.M., for status.
  • 08/23/2012
    Hearing Report - Administrative Law Judge Ruling

    Company Rebuttal Testimony to be filed and served on September 20, 2012; Staff Rebuttal Testimony to be filed and servied on October 18, 2012 and Company Surrebuttal to be filed and served on November 15, 2012.
  • 08/14/2012
    Service - Administrative Law Judge Ruling

    Notice given by the Administrative Law Judge that the schedule for filing testimony has changed in that the direct testimony of Staff and the intervenors is now due to be filed and served on August 16, 2012. All other dates remain the same. Notice served electronically to parties.
  • 08/10/2012
    Filing - Errata

    Errata (by Letter) to Direct Testimony on behalf of Commonwealth Edison Company, filed by Eimer Stahl LLP. (Electronic)
  • 08/01/2012
    Transcript - Received

    Transcript - July 18, 2012, received.
  • 07/20/2012
    Service - Hearing Continuance Letter

    Hearing continued by the Administrative Law Judge to August 23, 2012 in Chicago at 11:30 A.M. Notice served elecronically to parties.
  • 07/18/2012
    Hearing Report - Heard and Continued

    Heard by Administrative Law Judge Sainsot and continued to August 23, 2012, in Chicago, at 11:30 A.M.
  • 07/18/2012
    Hearing Report - Administrative Law Judge Ruling

    Leave to Intervene was granted to CUB and the IPA. ComEd has to and including July 25, 2012 to file and serve Direct Testimony. Staff the the Intervenors have to and including August 13, 2012, to file and serve Direct Testimony.
  • 07/18/2012
    Transcript - Pending

    Transcript pending.
  • 07/18/2012
    Filing - Appearance

    Appearance on behalf of the Illinois Power Agency, filed by Kelley Drye & Warren LLP. (Electronic)
  • 06/21/2012
    Filing - Report

    Evaluation Report on Commonwealth Edison Company's Energy Efficiency/Demand Response Measures for the 2010-2011 Plan Year, filed. (Electronic)
  • 06/13/2012
    Filing - Appearance

    Notice of Substitution of Counsel and Appearances on behalf of Commonwealth Edison Company, filed by Eimer Stahl, LLP. (Electronic)
  • 05/17/2012
    Filing - Appearance

    Additional Appearances on behalf of Commonwealth Edison Company, filed by Eimer Stahl LLP. (Electronic)
  • 04/18/2012
    Service - Hearing Continuance Letter

    Hearing continued by the Administrative Law Judge to July 18, 2012, in Chicago at 11:30 A.M., for status. Notice served electronically to parties.
  • 04/17/2012
    Hearing Report - Continued w/o Hearing

    Case continued on Hearing Report by Administrative Law Judge Sainsot to July 18, 2012, in Chicago, at 11:30 A.M., for status.
  • 02/08/2012
    Filing - Appearance

    Additional Appearance on behalf of the People of the State of Illinois, filed. (Electronic)
  • 11/02/2011
    Filing - Petition to Intervene

    Verified Petition to Intervene on behalf of the People of the State of Illinois, filed. (Electronic)
  • 10/05/2011
    Transcript - Received

    Transcript - September 21, 2011, received.
  • 09/22/2011
    Service - Hearing Continuance Letter

    Hearing continued by the Administrative Law Judge to April 17, 2012, in Chicago at 11:00 A.M. Notice also given by the Administrative Law Judge of the following schedule: ComEd shall file and serve its energy efficiency report within 30 days of its receipt (by ComEd); and Within 60 days from receipt of this report, ComEd shall file and serve its initial prefiled testimony. Notice served electronically to parties.
  • 09/21/2011
    Hearing Report - Heard and Continued

    Heard by Administrative Law Judge Sainsot and continued to April 17, 2012, in Chicago, at 11:00 A.M.
  • 09/21/2011
    Transcript - Pending

    Transcript pending.
  • 09/20/2011
    Filing - Petition to Intervene

    Verified Petition to Intervene of the Citizens Utility Board, filed. (Electronic)
  • 09/13/2011
    Filing - Appearance

    Entry of Appearance of Commonwealth Edison Company, filed. (Electronic)
  • 08/31/2011
    Service - Setting/Prehearing Conference

    Set for status hearing by the Administrative Law Judge on September 21, 2011, in Chicago at 2:00 P.M. Notice served electronically to parties.
  • 08/29/2011
    Filing - Petition to Intervene

    Petition to Intervene on behalf of the Illinois Power Agency, filed by Kelley Drye & Warren LLP. (Electronic)
  • 08/23/2011
    Filing - Report

    Energy Division Staff Report to Initiate an Investigation into whether Commonwealth Edison met its 3 Energy Savings Goals dated August 19, 2011, filed. (mailed by Interoffice Mail)
  • 08/23/2011
    Order Entered - Initiating Proceeding

    Initiating Order entered.
  • 08/23/2011
    Service - Order

    Copy of Initiating Order served electronically to parties.