Case Number: 12-0512

Consolidations

  • 10/30/2013 5:00 PM
    Briefs

    Reply Briefs and Statements of Position/Draft Orders are due October 30, 2013.
  • 10/23/2013 5:00 PM
    Briefs

    Initial Briefs are due on October 23, 2013.
  • 10/10/2013 10:00 AM
    Hearing

    Evidentiary Hearing.Evidentiary Hearing. Hearing went as scheduled and Continued Generally. EXHIBITS ADMITTED AS FILED ON E-DOCKET: [NS-PGL Ex. 53.0, 53.1N, 53.1P, 53.2N, 53.2P, 53.3N, 53.3P, 53.4N, 53.4P – Direct Testimony of John Hengtgen on Rehearing and Accompanying Exhibits (filed 9/5/13) - Admitted NS-PGL Ex. 53.5 – Affidavit of John Hengtgen (filed 10/10/13) - Admitted NS-PGL Ex. 52.0, 52.1N, 52.1P. 52.2N, 52.2P, 52.3N, 52.3P, 52.4N, 52.4P – Direct Testimony of Sharon Moy on Rehearing and Accompanying Exhibits (filed 9/5/13) - Admitted NS-PGL Ex. 54.0, 54.1N, 54.1P, 54.2 – Reply Testimony of Sharon Moy on Rehearing and Accompanying Exhibits (filed 10/3/13) - Admitted] [ICC Staff Exhibit 26.0, 26.1, 26.2 – Rebuttal Testimony of Dianna Hathhorn on Rehearing and Accompanying Exhibits (filed 9/19/13) - Admitted ICC Staff Exhibit 27.0 – Affidavit of Dianna Hathhorn (filed 10/9/13) – Admitted]CROSS EXHIBITS ADMITTED IN HARD COPY: [ICC Staff Cross Exhibit 1 On Rehearing – PGL’s Response to Staff Data Requests ACC 1.01-1.09 (dated 8/6/13) – Admitted ICC Staff Cross Exhibit 2 On Rehearing – PGL’s Response to Staff Data Requests ACC 2.01-2.02 (dated 8/22/13) – Admitted]
  • 10/03/2013 5:00 PM
    Testimony

    Reply Testimony is due on October 3, 2013.
  • 09/19/2013 5:00 PM
    Rebuttal

    Rebuttal Testimony is due on September 19,2013.
  • 09/17/2013 10:00 AM
    Hearing

    Hearing
  • 09/17/2013 10:00 AM
    Ruling

    The previous schedule is revised to reflect Rebuttal Testimony is due on September 19, 2013 instead of September 26, 2013. The rest of the schedule remains unchanged.
  • 09/05/2013 5:00 PM
    Direct

    Direct Testimony on Rehearing of the Companies is due September 5, 2013.
  • 08/22/2013 10:00 AM
    Hearing

    Status on Re-Hearing.
  • 08/22/2013 10:00 AM
    Ruling

    Direct Testimony on Rehearing of the Companies is due September 5, 2013. Rebuttal Testimony is due on September 26,2013. Reply Testimony is due on October 3, 2013. Hearing is scheduled for October 10, 2013 at 10:00 A.M. Initial Briefs are due on October 23, 2013. Reply Briefs and Statements of Position/Draft Orders are due October 30, 2013.
  • 08/08/2013 5:00 PM
    Deadline

    Deadline for Commission action on Petitions for Rehearing filed on July 19, 2013.
  • 06/23/2013 5:00 PM
    Deadline

    Approximate date for Final Order
  • 05/24/2013 5:00 PM
    Replies to Response

    Any reply to the response filed is due by May 24, 2012.”
  • 05/22/2013 5:00 PM
    Deadline

    the Reply Brief on Exceptions of the Staff of The Illinois Commerce Commission is due on May 22, 2013.
  • 05/20/2013 12:47 PM
    Ruling

    “Any response to North Shore Gas Company's and The Peoples Gas Light and Coke Company's Motion to Strike, In Part, the Reply Brief on Exceptions of the Staff of the Illinois Commerce Commission is due on May 22, 2013. Any reply to the response filed is due by May 24, 2012.”
  • 04/24/2013 4:15 PM
    Ruling

    North Shore's and Peoples Gas' Motion to Admit Evidence on 2013 Debt Costs is granted and the record is marked “heard and taken”
  • 04/22/2013 5:00 PM
    Replies to Response

    Any reply by the Utilities is due by April 22, 2013.
  • 04/19/2013 5:00 PM
    Responses to Motion

    Any response to the Utilities‘Motion to Admit Evidence on 2013 Debt Costs is due on April 19, 2013.
  • 04/17/2013 3:21 PM
    Ruling

    Any response to the Utilities‘Motion to Admit Evidence on 2013 Debt Costs is due on April 19, 2013. Any reply by the Utilities is due by April 22, 2013.
  • 03/28/2013 5:00 PM
    Deadline

    Draft Orders/Statements of Positions due on or before March 28, 2013.
  • 03/26/2013 5:00 PM
    Briefs

    Simultaneous Reply Briefs due on or before March 26, 2013.
  • 03/13/2013 11:31 AM
    Ruling

    Notice is hereby given by the Administrative Law Judges that the Motion to Correct the Transcript of the February 4-8, 13, 2013 Hearings filed by North Shore Gas Company and the Peoples Gas Light and Coke Company is granted.
  • 03/08/2013 5:00 PM
    Briefs

    Simultaneous Initial Briefs due on or before March 8, 2013.
  • 03/06/2013 2:16 PM
    Ruling

    “By agreement of the parties, Simultaneous Initial Briefs will be due March 8, 2012 and Simultaneous Reply Briefs will be due on March 26, 2013.”
  • 02/15/2013 5:00 PM
    Deadline

    Outline agreed upon by the parties to be followed in Briefs and Draft Orders/Statements of Positions due on or before February 15, 2013.
  • 02/13/2013 10:00 AM
    Hearing

    Hearing went as scheduled & continued Generally - EXHIBITS ADMITTED AS FILED ON E-DOCKET: [NS-PGL Ex. 36.0 – Rebuttal Testimony of Debra Egelhoff (filed 12/18/12) – Admitted NS-PGL Ex. 50.0 – Surrebuttal Testimony of Debra Egelhoff (filed 1/25/13) – Admitted IGS Ex. 1.0 – Corrected Direct Testimony of Vincent Parisi (filed 2/13/13) - Admitted IGS Exs. 2.0, 2.1 through 2.3 – Corrected Rebuttal Testimony of Vincent Parisi (filed 2/13/13) – Admitted IGS Ex. 3.0 – Affidavit of Vincent Parisi (filed 2/13/13) – Admitted ICC Staff Exs. 24.0, 24.02N (public and confidential version), 24.06N Revised, 24.07P Revised, 24.08P Revised – Surrebuttal Testimony of Daniel Kahle (filed 2/11/13 and 2/14/13) – Admitted ICC Staff Exs. 25.0, 25.01N Revised and 25.01P Revised – Surrebuttal Testimony of Mike Ostander (filed 2/11/13 and 2/14/13) – Admitted] EXHIBITS ADMITTED IN HARD COPY: [IGS Cross Ex. 8 – Screenshot of NS’ What are My Choices Section of its Website (printed 2/3/13) – Admitted IGS Cross Ex. 9 – Screenshot of PGL’s What are My Choices Section of its Website (printed 2/3/13) – Admitted IGS Cross Ex. 24 – Pages 5-9 of the ICC’s 2007 Annual Report of Natural Gas Markets in Illinois – Admitted IGS Cross Ex. 25 – PGL’s quarterly report submitted in compliance with Finding (9) and the third Ordering Paragraph of the ICC’s 3/5/02 Order for the quarter ended 3/31/10 (dated 4/6/10) – Admitted IGS Cross Ex. 26 – PGL’s quarterly report submitted in compliance with Finding (9) and the third Ordering Paragraph of the ICC’s 3/5/02 Order for the quarter ended 12/31/12 (dated 1/7/13) - Admitted]
  • 02/08/2013 9:30 AM
    Ruling

    Petition to Intervene of Local Union No. 18007, Utility Workers Union of America, AFL-CIO - Granted
  • 02/08/2013 9:30 AM
    Hearing

    Evidentiary Hearing. HEARING WENT AS SCHEDULED - EXHIBITS ADMITTED AS FILED ON E-DOCKET: [NS Exs. 13.0 through 13.8 – Direct Testimony of Joylyn Hoffman Malueg (filed 7/31/12) – Admitted PGL Exs. 13.0 through 13.8 – Direct Testimony of Joylyn Hoffman Malueg (filed 7/31/12) – Admitted NS-PGL Exs. 33.0 through 33.15 – Rebuttal Testimony of Joylyn Hoffman Malueg (filed 12/181/12) – Admitted Union Ex. 1.0 – Rebuttal Testimony of Richard Passarelli (filed 1/18/13) – Admitted NS Exs. 10.0 and 10.1– Direct Testimony of John Stabile (filed 7/31/12) – Admitted PGL Exs. 10.0 and 10.1– Direct Testimony of John Stabile (filed 7/31/12) – Admitted NS-PGL Exs. 30.0 REV and 30.1 – Rebuttal Testimony of John Stabile (filed 1/8/13 and 12/8/12) – Admitted NS-PGL Exs. 46.0 and 46.1 – Surrebuttal Testimony of John Stabile (filed 1/25/13) – Admitted CUB-City Exs.1.0 through 1.4 – Direct Testimony of Ralph Smith (filed 11/20/12) – Admitted CUB-City Exs. 2.0 and 2.1 – Rebuttal Testimony of Ralph Smith (filed 1/16/13) – Admitted CUB-City Ex. 3.0 – Affidavit of Ralph Smith (filed 2/7/13) – Admitted NS Exs. 12.0 REV, 12.1 through 12.11 – Direct Testimony of Valerie Grace (filed 2/8/13 and 7/31/12) – Admitted PGL Exs. 12.0 REV, 12.1 through 12.11 – Direct Testimony of Valerie Grace (filed 2/8/13 and 7/31/12) – Admitted NS-PGL Exs. 32.0 through 32.17 – Rebuttal Testimony of Valerie Grace (filed 12/18/12) – Admitted NS-PGL Exs. 48.0 REV, 48.1 through 48.4 – Surrebuttal Testimony of Valerie Grace (filed 2/8/13 and 1/25/13) – Admitted] EXHIBITS ADMITTED IN HARD COPY: [ICC Staff Cross Ex. 12 – NS’ Response to Staff Data Request BAP 15.01 (dated 10/23/12) – Admitted ICC Staff Cross Ex. 13 – PGL’s Response to Staff Data Request BAP 15.01 (dated 10/23/12) – Admitted ICC Staff Cross Ex. 14 – NS’ Response to Staff Data Request BAP 19.01 (dated 11/15/12) – Admitted ICC Staff Cross Ex. 15 – PGL’s Response to Staff Data Request BAP 19.01 (dated 11/15/12) – Admitted AG Cross Ex. 22 – NS’ Response to AG Data Request AG 15.11 (dated 12/20/12) – Admitted AG Cross Ex. 23 – Cover page, table of contents, pages 1 and 36-38 of Direct Testimony of Martin Fruehe in Docket 12-0321 – Admitted AG Cross Ex. 24 – History of North Shore Residential (S.C. 1) Rates: 2007 to Present – Admitted AG Cross Ex. 25 – History of Peoples Gas Light Residential (S.C. 1) Rates: 2007 to Present – Admitted IGS Cross Ex. 15 – NS’ Response to IGS Data Requests IGS 1.16 (dated 11/5/12) – Admitted IGS Cross Ex. 16 – NS’ Response to IGS Data Requests IGS 3.03 (dated 1/7/13) – Admitted IGS Cross Ex. 17 – NS’ Response to IGS Data Requests IGS 3.04 (dated 1/7/13) – Admitted IGS Cross Ex. 19 – NS’ Response to IGS Data Requests IGS 2.08 (dated 12/28/12) – Admitted IGS Cross Ex. 20 – Screenshot of Nicor Gas Company’s List on its Website of Total Customers Enrolled in its Customer Select Program (printed on 2/8/13) - Admitted IGS Cross Ex. 21 – Screenshot of PGL’s List on its Website of Alternative Natural Gas Suppliers (printed on 2/5/13) - Admitted IGS Cross Ex. 22 – Screenshot of NS’ List on its Website of Alternative Natural Gas Suppliers (printed on 2/5/13) - Admitted IGS Cross Ex. 23 – Screenshot of Nicor Gas Company’s List on its Website of Participating Suppliers (printed 2/6/13) – Admitted]
  • 02/07/2013 9:30 AM
    Hearing

    Evidentiary Hearing. Hearing went as scheduled - EXHIBITS ADMITTED AS FILED ON E-DOCKET: [1. List by exhibit number and title used on e-Docket all pre-filed testimony on e-Docket that was admitted into evidence. NS Exs. 7.0 through 7.3 – Direct Testimony of John Hengtgen (filed 7/31/12) – Admitted PGL Exs. 7.0 through 7.3 – Direct Testimony of John Hengtgen (filed 7/31/12) – Admitted NS-PGL Exs. 19.0, 19.1N, 19.3N, 19.1P, 19.2P REV, 19.3P, 19.4P – Supplemental Direct Testimony of John Hengtgen (filed 10/23/12 and 12/13/12) – Admitted NS-PGL Exs. 27.0, 27.1N through 27.10N, 27.12N through 27.14N, 27.1P through 27.14P – Rebuttal Testimony of John Hengtgen (filed 12/18/12) – Admitted NS-PGL Exs. 43.0, 43.1N, 43.2N, 43.4N through 43.8N, 43.1P through 43.8P – Surrebuttal Testimony of John Hengtgen (filed 1/25/13) – Admitted ICC Staff Exs. 8.0, 8.01N and P through 8.02N and P – Direct Testimony of William Johnson (filed 11/20/12) – Admitted ICC Staff Ex. 17.0 and Attachment A – Rebuttal Testimony of William Johnson (filed 1/16/13) – Admitted ICC Staff Exs. 6.0, 6.01P, Attachments A, B1 and B2 – Direct Testimony of Brett Seagle (filed 11/20/12) – Admitted ICC Staff Exs. 16.0, 16.01P and Attachments A and B – Rebuttal Testimony of Brett Seagle (filed 1/16/13) – Admitted (Including corrections made to 16.01P as followings: in line 13, “line 6” should replace “line 7” and in line 14 “line 12” should replace “line 14”) ICC Staff Exs. 4.0, 4.01N and P, 4.02P, 4.03N and P through 4.04N and P, 4.05P and Attachments A and B – Direct Testimony of Bonita Pearce (filed 11/20/12) – Admitted ICC Staff Exs. 14.0, 14.01N and P, 14.02P, 14.03N and P and Attachment A – Rebuttal Testimony of Bonita Pearce (filed 1/16/13) – Admitted AG Exs. 2.0 and 2.1 – Direct Testimony of David Effron (filed 11/20/12) – Admitted AG Exs. 5.0, 5.1 (public and confidential version) and 5.2 (public and confidential) – Rebuttal Testimony of David Effron (filed 1/16/13) – Admitted AG Ex. 5.3 – Affidavit of David Effron (2/7/13) – Admitted AG Exs. 3.0 through 3.10 – Direct Testimony of Scott Rubin (filed 11/20/12) – Admitted AG Exs. 6.0 through 6.4 – Rebuttal Testimony of Scott Rubin (filed 1/16/13) – Admitted AG Ex. 6.5 – Affidavit of Scott Rubin (filed 2/6/13) – Admitted PGL Exs. 15.0, 15.1, 15.2 through 15.4 (confidential and public versions of each), PGL 15.5 – Direct Testimony of Thomas Puracchio (filed 7/31/12) – Admitted NS-PGL Ex. 35.0 – Rebuttal Testimony of Thomas Puracchio (filed 12/18/12) – Admitted NS-PGL Ex. 35.1 – Affidavit of Thomas Puracchio (filed 2/6/13) – Admitted ICC Staff Ex. 1.0, 1.01N and P through 1.07N and P – Direct Testimony of Dianna Hathhorn (filed 11/20/12) – Admitted ICC Staff Ex. 11.0, 11.01N and P through 11.07N and P – Rebuttal Testimony of Dianna Hathhorn (filed 1/16/13) – Admitted ICC Staff Ex. 11.1 – Affidavit of Dianna Hathhorn (filed 2/4/13) – Admitted ICC Staff Ex. 9.0 – Direct Testimony of Alicia Allen (filed 11/20/12) – Admitted ICC Staff Ex. 9.1 – Affidavit of Alicia Allen (filed 2/4/13) – Admitted ICC Staff Ex. 22.0 – Rebuttal Testimony of Rochelle Phipps (filed 1/16/13) – Admitted ICC Staff Ex. 22.1 – Affidavit of Rochelle Phipps (filed 2/4/13) – Admitted ICC Staff Ex. 19.0 and Attachments 1, 2 and 3 – Rebuttal Testimony of Darin Burk (filed 1/16/13) – Admitted ICC Staff Ex. 19.1 – Affidavit of Darin Burk (filed 2/5/13) - Admitted ICC Staff Ex. 21.0 (public and confidential version) and Attachments A through P – Rebuttal Testimony of David Sackett (filed 1/16/13) – Admitted ICC Staff Ex. 21.1 – Affidavit of David Sackett (filed 2/6/13) – Admitted ICC Staff Ex. 7.0 – Direct Testimony of Christopher Boggs (filed 11/20/12) – Admitted] HARD COPY EXHIBITS ADMITTED: [ICC Staff Ex. 7.1 – Affidavit of Christopher Boggs (filed 2/4/13) - Admitted 2. List by exhibit number and title all other exhibits admitted into evidence. ICC Staff Cross Ex. 10 – PGL’s Response to Staff Data Request BAP 26.01 (dated 1/28/13) – Admitted ICC Staff Cross Ex. 11 – PGL’s Response to Staff Data Request DLH 3.01 (dated 1/29/13) - Admitted AG Cross Ex. 16 – PGL’s Response to AG Data Request AG 22.10 (dated 1/28/13) – Admitted AG Cross Ex. 17 – PGL’s Response to AG Data Request AG 22.11 (dated 1/28/13) – Admitted AG Cross Ex. 18 – PGL’s Response to AG Data Request AG 22.12 (dated 1/28/13) – Admitted AG Cross Ex. 19 – Response to AG Data Request AG 1.04 to Staff (dated 2/4/13) – Admitted AG Cross Ex. 20 – Response to AG Data Request AG 1.05 to Staff (dated 2/4/13) – Admitted City Cross Ex. 1 – PGL’s Response to AG Data Request AG 15.05 (dated 12/20/12) – Admitted City Cross Ex. 2 – PGL’s Response to Staff Data Request DGK 7.06 (dated 9/26/12) – Admitted NS-PGL Cross Ex. 10 – Response to PGL and NS Data Request PGL-NS 3.13 to Staff – Admitted NS-PGL Cross Ex. 11 – Response to NS’ and PGL’s Data Request 12.05 to Staff (dated 2/1/13) - Admitted NS-PGL Cross Ex. 12 – Response to NS’ and PGL’s Data Request 12.06 to Staff - Admitted NS-PGL Cross Ex. 13 – Response to NS’ and PGL’s Data Request 14.01 to Staff – Admitted NS-PGL Cross Ex. 14 – PGL’s Response to Staff Data Request BAP 27.02 (dated 1/28/13) – Admitted NS-PGL Cross Ex. 15 – AG’s Response to PGL’s and NS’ Data Requests 2.03, 2.07, 2.14, 2.15, 8.02 – Admitted]
  • 02/07/2013 9:30 AM
    Ruling

    Motion to Strike Certain Surrebuttal Testimony of Peoples Gas Light & Coke Company and North Shore Gas Company filed by the Attorney General – Denied Request by Staff for leave for Staff and Intervenors to file Surrebuttal Testimony responding to the Companies’ Surrebuttal Testimony related to the 2012 Taxpayer Relief Act – Granted (Staff and Intervenor Surrebuttal Testimony due by 2/11/13)
  • 02/06/2013 9:30 AM
    Ruling

    Motion to Strike a Portion of the Surrebuttal Testimony of Kyle Hoops filed by Staff – Denied Motion to Strike and Deny the Peoples Gas Light and Coke Company’s and North Shore Gas Company’s Request for a Conditional SFV Tariff filed by the Attorney General – Denied
  • 02/06/2013 9:30 AM
    Hearing

    Evidentiary Hearing. HEARING WENT AS SCHEDULED - EXHIBITS ADMITTED AS FILED ON E-DOCKET: [NS Exs. 8.0 and 8.1 – Direct Testimony of Kyle Hoops (filed 7/31/12) – Admitted PGL Exs. 8.0, 8.1 and 8.2 (confidential and public version) – Direct Testimony of Kyle Hoops (filed 7/31/12) – Admitted NS-PGL Exs. 20.0 and 20.1 – Supplemental Direct Testimony of Kyle Hoops (filed 10/23/12) – Admitted NS-PGL Exs. 28.0 REV, 28.1 (confidential and public version), 28.2, 28.3 REV (confidential and public version), 28.4 (confidential and public version) – Rebuttal Testimony of Kyle Hoops (filed 1/8/13 and 12/18/12) – Admitted NS-PGL Exs. 44.0, 44.1 (confidential and public version), 44.2 and 44.3 – Surrebuttal Testimony of Kyle Hoops (1/25/13) – Admitted NS Ex. 1.0 REV – Direct Testimony of James Schott (filed 2/1/13) – Admitted PGL Ex. 1.0 REV – Direct Testimony of James Schott (filed 2/1/13) – Admitted NS-PGL Ex. 22 2nd REV – Rebuttal Testimony of James Schott (filed 2/6/13) – Admitted NS-PGL 37.0 – Surrebuttal Testimony of James Schott (filed 1/25/13) – Admitted AG Exs. 1.0 through 1.12 – Direct Testimony of Michael Brosch (filed 11/20/12) – Admitted AG Exs. 4.0, 4.1 (confidential and public version), 4.2 through 4.6 Revised, 4.7 through 4.11 – Rebuttal Testimony of Michael Brosch (filed 11/20/12,1/16/13 and 2/6/13) – Admitted NS Exs. 3.0 through 3.13 – Direct Testimony of Paul Moul (filed 7/31/12) – Admitted PGL Exs. 3.0 through 3.13 – Direct Testimony of Paul Moul (filed 7/31/12) – Admitted NS-PGL Exs. 24.0 REV, 24.1 and 24.2 – Rebuttal Testimony of Paul Moul (filed 1/8/13 and 12/18/12) – Admitted NS-PGL Ex. 39.0 – Surrebuttal Testimony of Paul Moul (filed 1/25/13) – Admitted ICC Staff Exs. 5.0, 5.01, 5.02N and P through 5.03N and P, and 5.04 through 5.08 – Direct Testimony of Michael McNally (filed 11/20/12) – Admitted ICC Staff Exs.15.0, 15.01, 15.02N and P, and Attachments A through D – Rebuttal Testimony of Michael McNally (filed 1/16/13) – Admitted ICC Staff Ex. 15.1 – Affidavit of Michael McNally (filed 2/4/13) – Admitted] HARD COPY EXHIBITS ADMITTED: [AG Cross Ex. 11 – PGL’s Response to AG Data Request AG 22.13 (Attachment CONFIDENTIAL) (dated 1/28/13 – Admitted AG Cross Ex. 12 – PGL’s Response to AG Data Request AG 16.24 (dated 12/20/12) – Admitted AG Cross Ex. 13 – PGL’s Response to AG Data Request AG 10.25 (dated 10/26/12) – Admitted AG Cross Ex. 15 – PGL’s Response to AG Data Request AG 22.01 (dated 1/28/13) – Admitted IGS Energy Cross Ex. 10 – Screenshot of NS’ Vision, Mission & Values Section of its Website (printed on 2/3/13) – Admitted IGS Energy Cross Ex. 11– Screenshot of PGL’s Vision, Mission & Values Section of its Website (printed on 2/3/13) – Admitted NS-PGL Cross Ex. 4 – AG’s Response to PGL’s and NS’ Data Request 6.01 (dated 1/24/13) – Admitted NS-PGL Cross Ex. 5 – AG’s Response to PGL’s and NS’ Data Request 6.08 (dated 1/24/13) - Admitted NS-PGL Cross Ex. 6 – AG’s Response to PGL’s and NS’ Data Request 6.09 (dated 1/24/13) - Admitted NS-PGL Cross Ex. 7 – AG’s Response to PGL’s and NS’ Data Request 6.10 (dated 1/24/13) - Admitted NS-PGL Cross Ex. 9 – Stock Observation Data (hard copy and CD) – Admitted ICC Staff Cross Ex. 8 – Group Exhibit (NS-PGL Ex. 39.0 WP-1, PGL Response to MGM 7.01 (PGL 0023143) and PGL MGM 7.01 Attach (PGL 0023144 to PGL 0023152)) – Admitted ICC Staff Cross Ex. 9 – Group Exhibit (NS-PGL Ex. 39 WP-2, PGL Response to MGM 7.02 (PGL 0023153) and PGL MGM 7.02 Attach 01 (PGL 0023154 to PGL 0023161) - Admitted]
  • 02/05/2013 9:30 AM
    Hearing

    Evidentiary Hearing. HEARING WENT AS SCHEDULED - EXHIBITS ADMITTED AS FILED ON E-DOCKET: [PGL Ex. 14.0 – Direct Testimony of Phillip Hayes (filed 7/31/12) – Admitted NS-PGL Exs. 21.0 and 21.1 – Supplemental Direct Testimony of Phillip Hayes (filed 10/23/12) – Admitted NS-PGL Exs. 34.0 (confidential and public version), 34.1 through 34.5 – Rebuttal Testimony of Phillip Hayes (filed 12/18/12) – Admitted NS-PGL Exs. 49.0 CORR (confidential and public version),49.1 through 49.6, 49.7 (confidential and public version), 49.8 through 49.10 – Surrebuttal Testimony of Phillip Haynes (filed 2/1/13) – Admitted NS Exs. 2.0 through 2.7 – Direct Testimony of Lisa Gast (filed 7/31/12) – Admitted PGL Exs. 2.0 through 2.7 – Direct Testimony of Lisa Gast (filed 7/31/12) – Admitted NS-PGL Exs. 17.0, 17.1N, 17.2N, 17.1P and 17.2P – Supplemental Direct Testimony of Lisa Gast (filed 10/23/12) – Admitted NS-PGL Exs. 23.0, 23.1N, 23.1P, 23.2N, 23.2P, 23.3N, 23.3P, 23.4 and 23.5 (confidential and public version) – Rebuttal Testimony of Lisa Gast (filed 12/18/12) – Admitted NS-PGL Exs. 38.0, 38.1N and 38.1P – Surrebuttal Testimony of Lisa Gast (filed 1/25/13) – Admitted NS Ex. 4.0 – Direct Testimony of Kevin Kuse (filed 1/31/12) – Admitted PGL Ex. 4.0 – Direct Testimony of Kevin Kuse (filed 1/31/12) – Admitted NS-PGL Exs. 40.0 through 40.5 – Surrebuttal Testimony of Kevin Kuse (filed 1/25/13) – Admitted ICC Staff Exs. 3.0, 3.01N and P (confidential and public versions), 3.02N and P through 3.08N and P, 3.09P and Attachments A and B – Direct Testimony of Mike Ostrander (filed 11/20/12) – Admitted ICC Staff Exs. 10.0, 10.10N and P – Supplemental Direct Testimony of Mike Ostrander (filed 12/6/12) – Admitted ICC Staff Exs. 13.0, 13.01N and P, 13.02N and P Revised, 13.03N and P, 13.04N and P, 13.05P and Attachments A through F – Rebuttal Testimony of Mike Ostrander (filed 1/16/13 and 2/5/13) – Admitted ICC Staff Ex. 18.0 – Rebuttal Testimony of David Rearden (filed 1/16/13) – Admitted ICC Staff Ex. 20.0, 20.01 through 20.04 – Rebuttal Testimony of Philliph Roy Buxton (filed 1/17/13) – Admitted] EXHIBITS ADMITTED IN HARD COPY: [AG Cross Ex. 6 – PGL’s Response to AG Data Request AG 14.08 (dated 12/7/12) – Admitted AG Cross Ex. 7 – PGL’s Response to AG Data Request AG 14.02 (dated 12/7/12) – Admitted AG Cross Ex. 8 – PGL’s Response to AG Data Request AG 10.17 (dated 10/26/12) – Admitted AG Cross Ex. 9 – Group Exhibit (PGL Responses to AG Data Requests AG 10.15, 10.16, 10.18, 18.01, 18.03, 18.05, 18.06, 18.08 with Attachment 1, 18.11 through 18.14 and PGL Reponses to City Data Requests City 2.01 through 2.06) - Admitted NS-PGL Redirect Ex. 2 - PGL’s Response to AG Data Request AG 18.09 (dated 1/3/13) – Admitted AG Cross Ex. 10 – NS-PGL Ex. 23.0 WP-5 – Admitted NS-PGL Cross Ex. 3 – Cover Page and Page 19 of Rebuttal Testimony of Noreen Cleary (NS-PGL Ex. 25.0) in Docket 11-0280 and 11-0281 (cons.) – Admitted IGS Energy Cross Ex. 1 – Response to IGS’s Data Request IGS 1.06 to Staff (dated 2/1/13) – Admitted IGS Energy Cross Ex. 4 - Response to IGS’s Data Request IGS 1.12 to Staff (dated 2/1/13) – Admitted IGS Energy Cross Ex. 5 - Response to IGS’s Data Request IGS 1.09 to Staff (dated 2/1/13) – Admitted IGS Energy Cross Ex. 7 – Cover Page and Pages 46-47 of Rebuttal Testimony of David Sackett (ICC Staff Ex. 24.0) in Docket 08-0363 – Admitted (for limited purpose of impeachment)]
  • 02/04/2013 5:00 PM
    Replies to Response

    The Attorney General’s reply, if any, is due by February 4, 2013.
  • 02/04/2013 9:30 AM
    Hearing

    Evidentiary Hearing. Hearing went as scheduled - EXHIBITS ADMITTED AS FILED ON E-DOCKET: [NS Exs. 5.0 REV and 5.1 - Direct Testimony of Christine Gregor (filed 12/13/12 and 7/31/12) - Admitted PGL Exs. 5.0 REV and 5.1 - Direct Testimony of Christine Gregor (filed 12/13/12 and 7/31/12) - Admitted NS-PGL Ex. 16.0 - Supplemental Direct Testimony of Christine Gregor (filed 10/23/12) - Admitted NS-PGL Exs. 25.0, 25.1P, 25.2P, 25.3N, 25.3P, 25.4, 25.5, 25.6N and 25.6P - Rebuttal Testimony of Christine Gregor (filed 12/18/12) - Admitted NS-PGL Exs. 41.0 CORR, 41.1P, 41.2P, 41.3P CORR, 41.4N, 41.4P, 41.5 and 41.6 - Surrebuttal Testimony of Christine Gregor (filed 2/1/13 and 1/25/13) - Admitted NS Exs. 6.0 and 6.1 - Direct Testimony of Sharon Moy (filed 7/31/12) - Admitted PGL Exs. 6.0 and 6.1 - Direct Testimony of Sharon Moy (filed 7/31/12) - Admitted NS-PGL Exs. 18.0, 18.1N, 18.2N, 18.3N, 18.1P, 18.2P and 18.3P - Supplemental Direct Testimony of Sharon Moy (filed 10/23/12) - Admitted NS-PGL Exs. 26.0, 26.1N, 26.1P, 26.2N, 26.2P, 26.3N, 26.3P, 26.4, 26.5N, 26.5P, 26.6 through 26.13 (confidential and public versions), 26.14, 26.15 through 26.16 (confidential and public versions) and 26.17 through 26.20 - Rebuttal Testimony of Sharon Moy (filed 12/18/12) - Admitted NS-PGL Exs. 42.0 REV, 42.1N, 42.1P, 42.2N, 42.2P, 42.3, 42.4N, 42.4P, 42.5 through 42.9 (confidential and public versions) and 42.10 through 42.12 - Surrebuttal Testimony of Sharon Moy (filed 2/1/13 and 1/25/13) - Admitted NS Exs. 11.0 through 11.2 - Direct Testimony of Christine Phillips (filed 7/31/12) - Admitted PGL Exs. 11.0 through 11.2 - Direct Testimony of Christine Phillips (filed 7/31/12) - Admitted NS-PGL Exs. 31.0, 31.1N, 31.1P, 31.2N, 31.2P, 31.3N and 31.3P - Rebuttal Testimony of Christine Phillips (filed 12/18/12) - Admitted NS-PGL Exs. 47.0 and 47.1 - Surrebuttal Testimony of Christine Phillips (filed 1/25/13) - Admitted NS Exs. 9.0 and 9.1 - Direct Testimony of Noreen Cleary (filed 7/31/12) - Admitted PGL Ex. 9.0 and 9.1 - Direct Testimony of Noreen Cleary (filed 7/31/12) - Admitted NS-PGL Exs. 29.0 through 29.3 - Rebuttal Testimony of Noreen Cleary (filed 12/18/12) - Admitted NS-PGL Exs. 45.0 through 45.6 - Surrebuttal Testimony of Noreen Cleary (filed 1/25/13) - Admitted ICC Staff Exs. 2.0, 2.01N and P through 2.06N and P, 2.07P, 2.08P and Attachments A and B - Direct Testimony of Daniel Kahle (filed 11/20/12) - Admitted ICC Staff Exs. 12.0 Revised, 12.01N and P Revised, 12.02N, 12.03N and P through 12.05N and P, 12.06N Revised, 12.07P Revised and 12.08P Revised - Rebuttal Testimony of Daniel Kahle (filed 1/17/13, 1/24/13 and 2/4/13) - Admitted ICC Staff Exs. 23.0 and 23.02N - Supplemental Rebuttal Testimony of Daniel Kahle (filed 1/24/13) - Admitted] HARD COPY EXHIBITS ADMITTED: [ICC Staff Cross Ex. 1 - PGL's Response to Staff Data Request BAP 27.01 (dated 1/28/13) - Admitted ICC Staff Cross Ex. 2 - PGL's Response to Staff Data Request JMO 12.04 (dated 8/28/12) - Admitted ICC Staff Cross Ex. 3 - NS' Response to Staff Data Request JMO 12.05 (dated 8/28/12) - Admitted ICC Staff Cross Ex. 4 - PGL's Response to Staff Data Request BAP 26.02 (dated 1/28/13) - Admitted ICC Staff Cross Ex. 5 - PGL's Response to Staff Data Request JMO 24.03 (dated 11/2/12) - Admitted ICC Staff Cross Ex. 6 - PGL's Response to Staff Data Request JMO 24.03 (Supplemental Response) (dated 11/2/12) - Admitted ICC Staff Cross Ex. 7 - NS' Response to Staff Data Request JMO 24.05 (dated 11/2/12) - Admitted AG Cross Ex. 1 - PGL's Response to AG Data Request AG 8.19 (dated 10/19/12) - Admitted AG Cross Ex. 2 - NS' Response to AG Data Request AG 22.05 (dated 1/28/13) - Admitted AG Cross Ex. 3 - NS' Response to AG Data Request AG 22.06 (dated 1/28/13) - Admitted AG Cross Ex. 4 - NS' Response to AG Data Request AG 22.07 (dated 1/28/13) - Admitted AG Cross Ex. 5 - NS' Response to AG Data Request AG 22.08 (dated 1/28/13) - Admitted NS-PGL Redirect Ex. 1 - PGL's Response to AG Data Request AG 22.04 - Admitted NS-PGL Cross Ex. 1 - Response to NS' and PGL's Data Request 15.01 to Staff (dated 2/1/13) - Admitted NS-PGL Cross Ex. 2 - Reponse to NS' and PGL's Data Request 15.02 to Staff (dated 2/1/13) - Admitted]
  • 01/31/2013 5:00 PM
    Responses to Motion

    Responses to Pretrial Motions regarding Surrebuttal Testimony due on or before January 31, 2013 by noon.
  • 01/31/2013 5:00 PM
    Responses to Motion

    Responses to the Motion to Strike and Deny the Peoples Gas Light & Coke Company’s and North Shore Gas Company’s Request for a Conditional SFV Tariff filed by the Attorney General are due by January 31, 2013.
  • 01/31/2013 2:00 PM
    Hearing

    STATUS.
  • 01/29/2013 5:00 PM
    Motion

    Pretrial Motions regarding Surrebuttal Testimony due on or before January 29, 2013.
  • 01/29/2013 5:00 PM
    Deadline

    Notice is hereby given by the Administrative Law Judges that any objections to the Motion for Leave to File the Supplemental Rebuttal Testimony of Daniel Kahle filed by Staff of the Illinois Commerce Commission must be filed by January 29, 2013 at 10:00 a.m.
  • 01/29/2013 10:42 AM
    Ruling

    Notice is hereby given by the Administrative Law Judges that the Motion for Leave to File the Supplemental Rebuttal Testimony of Daniel Kahle filed by Staff of the Illinois Commerce Commission is granted.
  • 01/28/2013 9:47 AM
    Ruling

    Notice is hereby given by the Administrative Law Judges that any objections to the Motion for Leave to File the Supplemental Rebuttal Testimony of Daniel Kahle filed by Staff of the Illinois Commerce Commission must be filed by January 29, 2013 at 10:00 a.m.
  • 01/25/2013 5:00 PM
    Surrebuttal

    Companies Surrebuttal Testimony due on or before January 25, 2013.
  • 01/24/2013 12:30 PM
    Ruling

    Notice is hereby given by the Administrative Law Judges that responses to the Motion to Strike and Deny the Peoples Gas Light & Coke Company’s and North Shore Gas Company’s Request for a Conditional SFV Tariff filed by the Attorney General are due by January 31, 2013. The Attorney General’s reply, if any, is due by February 4, 2013.
  • 01/23/2013 5:00 PM
    Motion

    Pretrial Motions regarding Direct and Rebuttal Testimony due on or before January 23, 2013.
  • 01/16/2013 5:00 PM
    Rebuttal

    Staff and Intervenor Rebuttal Testimony due on or before January 16, 2013.
  • 12/27/2012 5:00 PM
    Deadline

    Resuspension deadline
  • 12/18/2012 5:00 PM
    Rebuttal

    Companies Rebuttal Testimony due on or before December 18, 2012.
  • 12/13/2012 2:30 PM
    Ruling

    Notice is hereby given by the Administrative Law Judges that the Motion for Leave to File the Supplemental Direct Testimony of Michael Ostrander filed by Staff of the Illinois Commerce Commission is granted.
  • 12/12/2012 5:00 PM
    Deadline

    Notice is hereby given by the Administrative Law Judges that any objections to the Motion for Leave to File the Supplemental Direct Testimony of Michael Ostrander filed by Staff of the Illinois Commerce Commission (“Staff”) must be filed by December 12, 2012.
  • 12/07/2012 11:07 AM
    Ruling

    Notice is hereby given by the Administrative Law Judges that any objections to the Motion for Leave to File the Supplemental Direct Testimony of Michael Ostrander filed by Staff of the Illinois Commerce Commission (“Staff”) must be filed by December 12, 2012.
  • 11/20/2012 5:00 PM
    Direct

    Staff and Intervenor Direct Testimony due on or before November 20, 2012.
  • 10/29/2012 3:10 PM
    Ruling

    Notice is hereby given by the Administrative Law Judges that the Motion for Entry of an Order Regarding Case Management Plan and Schedule filed by North Shore Gas Company and The Peoples Gas Light and Coke Company (collectively, the “Companies”) is granted.
  • 10/23/2012 5:00 PM
    Replies to Response

    The Companies’ reply, if any, is due by October 23, 2012.
  • 10/23/2012 5:00 PM
    Direct

    Companies Supplemental Direct Testimony due on or before October 23, 2012.
  • 10/18/2012 5:00 PM
    Responses to Motion

    Notice is hereby given by the Administrative Law Judges that responses to the Motion for Entry of an Order Regarding Case Management Plan and Schedule filed by North Shore Gas Company and The Peoples Gas Light and Coke Company (collectively, the “Companies”) are due by October 18, 2012.
  • 10/11/2012 3:08 PM
    Ruling

    Notice is hereby given by the Administrative Law Judges that responses to the Motion for Entry of an Order Regarding Case Management Plan and Schedule filed by North Shore Gas Company and The Peoples Gas Light and Coke Company (collectively, the “Companies”) are due by October 18, 2012. The Companies’ reply, if any, is due by October 23, 2012.
  • 10/09/2012 5:00 PM
    Replies to Response

    The Companies’ reply, if any, is due on October 9, 2012.
  • 10/04/2012 5:00 PM
    Responses to Motion

    Responses to the Motion for Entry of a Protective Order filed by North Shore Gas Company and The Peoples Gas Light and Coke Company (collectively, the “Companies”) are due on October 4, 2012.
  • 09/27/2012 10:43 AM
    Ruling

    Notice is hereby given by the Administrative Law Judges that responses to the Motion for Entry of a Protective Order filed by North Shore Gas Company and The Peoples Gas Light and Coke Company (collectively, the “Companies”) are due on October 4, 2012. The Companies’ reply, if any, is due on October 9, 2012.
  • 09/24/2012 1:30 PM
    Hearing

    STATUS.
  • 09/24/2012 1:30 PM
    Ruling

    Staff’s oral motion to consolidate Docket Nos. 12-0511 and 12-0512 was granted. The petitions to intervene filed by Interstate Gas Supply of Illinois, Inc. and Interstate Gas Supply, Inc. (collectively, “IGS Energy”) and the Citizens Utility Board were granted.